top of page

Pump and Dump Schemes: An Examination of Manipulative Market Practices

Updated: Feb 18


Pump and dump schemes represent a fraudulent type of stock market manipulation that can inflict serious financial damage on unsuspecting investors. This unethical practice involves the artificial inflation or 'pumping' of a stock's price, followed by the rapid selling or 'dumping' of the stock, leading to its inevitable collapse. This article aims to explore the intricate mechanisms of pump and dump schemes, provide illustrative examples, and enlighten investors on the red flags they should watch out for.



Understanding Pump and Dump Schemes


A pump and dump scheme starts when fraudsters invest in a low-priced or "penny" stock. These stocks typically belong to small, less established companies and are traded over the counter (OTC) or on smaller exchanges, where regulatory oversight might not be as stringent as larger exchanges. Once they've amassed a substantial position, the manipulators initiate the 'pump' phase, inflating the stock's price through misleading or outright false news stories, recommendations, or predictions of future earnings. These promotional activities aim to attract unsuspecting investors who buy the stock, thereby increasing demand and pushing its price even higher. Once the price has reached a certain inflated level, the fraudsters move into the 'dump' phase. They sell their shares at the elevated prices, making considerable profits. When they exit, the artificial demand evaporates, causing the stock price to drop dramatically. Those who bought in during the pump phase are left holding virtually worthless stocks and can suffer substantial losses.


Examples of Pump and Dump Schemes


The 'Classic' Email Spam Scheme: One of the most common examples of pump and dump in the modern era is through email spam. Here, fraudsters send out unsolicited emails to millions of recipients, promising insider information on a certain low-priced stock predicted to skyrocket. The emails often claim the sender has exclusive information, like impending news of a groundbreaking product or a major contract. The rush of buyers inflates the price, and the fraudsters sell their shares at the inflated prices. When the promised growth doesn't materialize, the stock price falls back to its original level or lower, leaving the duped investors at a loss.


The Infamous Case of Stratton Oakmont: Perhaps the most infamous real-world example of a pump and dump scheme was that carried out by Stratton Oakmont, the brokerage house made famous by the film "The Wolf of Wall Street." The company manipulated the prices of various penny stocks by providing misleading information, driving up their prices, then selling their holdings at the inflated prices. The stocks would then collapse, leaving other investors in a precarious position.


The Rise and Fall of Financial Influencers: With the increasing influence of social media, a new type of pump and dump scheme has emerged involving 'finfluencers', or financial influencers. These individuals leverage their significant online followings to manipulate stock prices. Here's an example. A well-known finfluencer, who has built a large audience by providing financial advice or sharing investment strategies, begins to heavily promote a little-known stock. They might praise the company's growth prospects, innovative product, or strong leadership team. The finfluencer might also claim to have insider information, asserting that the stock price is on the verge of skyrocketing. As followers trust the finfluencer's advice, they buy the stock, leading to an increase in its price. In some cases, this surge in demand can be substantial enough to significantly inflate the stock price. Meanwhile, the finfluencer, who had quietly accumulated a significant position in the stock before promoting it, sells their shares as the price peaks, raking in a tidy profit. Once this selling pressure becomes apparent, the stock price quickly falls back down, leaving the followers who had invested in the stock facing substantial losses. This sort of scheme can be particularly harmful because of the trust that followers place in the influencers they follow. This trust can lead them to invest without conducting their own thorough research. Therefore, it's always essential to verify any financial advice received online and to conduct independent research before making investment decisions.


Spotting the Red Flags


  • Unsolicited Stock Recommendations: As in the email spam example above, unsolicited stock advice, particularly for little-known companies, is often a red flag. Such advice can come via email, social media, or even phone calls.

  • Rapid Price Appreciation: A sudden rise in a stock's price without a corresponding increase in the financial health of the company may signal a pump and dump scheme. It's essential to scrutinize the reason behind the stock's price appreciation.

  • Limited Company Information: If the company in question trades over the counter or is a micro-cap stock, comprehensive information about its financial health might be difficult to find. Fraudsters often exploit these less regulated spaces.

  • High-Pressure Sales Tactics: Be wary of salespeople pressuring you to buy immediately, claiming that you're on the brink of missing a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.


Preventing Exposure to Pump and Dump Schemes


  • Thorough Research: Conduct thorough due diligence on any company whose stock you're considering buying. Review their financial statements, learn about the management team, and consider the viability of their product or service. If comprehensive information is not readily available, that should be considered a red flag.

  • Watch out for "Hot Tips" and Insider Information: Be skeptical of unsolicited "hot tips" or "insider information," especially if they pressure you to act quickly. Real investment opportunities are never based on secret information.

  • Be Wary of Hyperbolic Language: Promoters of pump and dump schemes often use hyperbolic and emotional language to create excitement and urgency. Be skeptical of statements that predict a specific stock price rise or that label an investment as a "once in a lifetime" opportunity.

  • Consult with a Financial Advisor: If you're unsure about an investment, consult with a financial advisor. Professionals are more experienced in detecting fraudulent activities.


Legal Consequences for Pump and Dump Schemes


Pump and dump schemes are illegal and are prosecuted by regulators such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the United States. These regulatory bodies have the authority to impose substantial fines and penalties on those found guilty of such schemes. Moreover, those involved can also face criminal charges, potentially leading to imprisonment.


An example of this is the case of the founders of Centra Tech, a cryptocurrency company. In 2018, the SEC charged the founders with orchestrating a fraudulent initial coin offering (ICO), which included false claims about business relationships with well-known credit card companies. After pumping the value of their cryptocurrency, they dumped their shares for significant profit. In 2020, one of the co-founders was sentenced to a year in prison.


Pump and dump schemes are a form of financial fraud that can result in substantial losses for investors. Awareness and education are the first steps toward prevention. By thoroughly researching investments, being skeptical of unsolicited stock tips, and consulting with trusted professionals, investors can reduce the likelihood of falling victim to these schemes. Regulators continue to work on detecting and prosecuting these frauds, but investor vigilance remains a key line of defense.


 

The pump and dump scheme is not only confined to the realm of the stock market. With the advent of digital assets like cryptocurrencies, this deceptive strategy has also found a new playing field. Cryptocurrencies, with their decentralized nature and often speculative market behavior, have become an attractive vehicle for such manipulative tactics. For instance, in the cryptocurrency market, an infamous event was the "Meme Coin" pump and dump scheme. In 2021, a large number of investors were lured into buying obscure, low-value cryptocurrencies, often inspired by internet memes. Promoters would artificially inflate the price through online hype, particularly on social media platforms. Once the price peaked, they would sell off their holdings, leading to a price collapse. This phenomenon led to the quick rise and fall of many so-called "meme coins," leaving many late-coming investors with significant losses.

19 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page