top of page

Why Retail Investors Should Avoid Options Trading

Options trading is an advanced investing strategy that involves a high degree of risk and complexity. While options can provide opportunities for experienced traders to hedge risk or speculate on directional moves, they are generally not suitable for the average retail investor. Here are some compelling reasons why most individual investors should steer clear of options trading:

Excessive Risk

One of the biggest pitfalls of options is the excessive risk involved. When trading options, you can potentially lose your entire investment in a relatively short period of time. This unlimited risk stems from the leverage employed with options. A single options contract may control 100 shares of the underlying stock, but costs significantly less than outright purchasing those 100 shares. This leverage magnifies both potential gains and losses.

Complex Pricing

Option prices are derived from a multitude of factors beyond just the price of the underlying security. Variables like time until expiration, implied volatility, and interest rates all influence an option's price in a complex way. Understanding how each factor impacts option premiums requires thorough technical knowledge that few retail investors possess. Getting the pricing wrong can lead to unintended consequences. Example: Say you want to buy a call option on XYZ stock trading at $50, with the goal of selling if it hits $55 within a month. You pay $2 for a $55 strike call expiring in 30 days. However, you may have failed to account for rapidly decreasing time value as expiration nears. Even if the stock rallies to $54.50 at expiration, your option could expire worthless if its premium doesn't exceed the $2 you paid.

Decision Paralysis

With a single options contract, there are numerous decisions that need to be made correctly: the strike price, the expiration date, whether to buy calls or puts, etc. And that's before even deciding when to enter or exit the trade. This myriad of choices can lead to decision paralysis or preventable errors for inexperienced traders. By contrast, buying stocks is a relatively simple decision.

Options are wasting assets, meaning they have a finite lifespan after which they expire worthless. This characteristic of time decay eats into the value of options as expiration approaches. Options buyers need to be right about the direction and timing of the price move to profit. This drag from time decay makes it very difficult for buy-and-hold investors to succeed with options over the long-term. Example: Say you buy a 6-month call option on ABC stock for $5 when it's trading at $100. If the stock remains flat at $100 over those 6 months, the option will be rendered worthless at expiration due to time decay eroding its value.

Excessive Leverage and Margin Requirements

To give options buyers and sellers the ability to Control a large number of shares despite limited capital, brokers allow traders to open positions requiring only a fraction of the cost to buy the shares outright. However, this leverage works both ways and can magnify losses just as easily as gains. Brokers may initiate margin calls during adverse moves, forcing traders to deposit additional funds or have their positions automatically liquidated.

High Transaction Costs

Options trading tends to involve high transaction costs that can eat into potential profits. Every time an option contract is bought or sold, the investor has to pay commissions to their broker. These commissions can add up quickly, especially for small traders opening and closing numerous positions. Example: Say you pay $10 per option trade at your broker. For a basic covered call strategy where you buy 100 shares of a stock and sell 1 call option contract against it, you'd pay $20 in commissions alone (buy stock + sell option). If the option expires worthless, that $20 in fees comes directly out of your trading profits.

Tax Complications

Unique tax rules apply to options trading that can make preparing tax returns very complicated for retail investors. Option transactions have different tax treatment depending on whether trades are closed out, expired, exercised, or if positions are opened and closed in different calendar years. These rules around tax lots, wash sales, constructive sales, etc. require excellent record keeping.

Emotional Mistakes

Trading options successfully requires incredible emotional discipline and patience - two skills that are extremely difficult for most retail investors to master. The lure of leverage and potential for large gains can cause investors to overtrade, overtake risk, or let emotions like fear and greed drive their decision making. These psychological pitfalls often lead to costly mistakes. Example: An investor buys an out-of-the-money call option on a hot stock, expecting it to continue rallying sharply. When the stock pulls back over the next few weeks, he falls victim to loss aversion and doubles down on more calls rather than cutting losses. This emotional decision compounds losses if the stock continues falling.

Given all these significant risks, costs, and difficulties, options trading is best left to professional traders at institutions with the expertise and resources to practice advanced options strategies responsibly. For individual investors, buying and holding a diversified portfolio will likely produce better returns over the long run with significantly less stress, cost, and complexity.

16 views0 comments


bottom of page